Skip to content

CA Foundation doubt

Is an agreement paying a government officer to retire so another person gets his post valid?

Guys can anyone solve this question I am a bit confused like it was in my test series and when I read this I literally got blank can anyone please explain this to me if possible

Image attached to the doubt: Guys can anyone solve this question I am a bit confused like it was in my test…

Asked by Nitika··3 answers

3 replies

  1. BrunoAI answerAI first answer — verify with your teacher

    The agreement is void. Its consideration and object are unlawful under Section 23 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872, because it is opposed to public policy. 1. Section 23: an agreement is void if its consideration or object is opposed to public policy. 2. Paying a public servant to retire so that another person gets his post is trafficking in public offices. Public posts must be filled on merit, not bought. 3. Mr. S's consent and the attractive amount (double his salary) do not matter. An illegal object cannot be cured by the parties' agreement. Conclusion: the agreement is void, so neither Mr. S nor Mr. D can enforce it.

  2. Rashi · 1 found helpful

    This question is straight forward, if you are not able to grasp the concept immediately, it means your revision is less, my advice is to read it again from sec 23.

  3. Pawani

    Application: Mr. D offered ₹10 lakh to Mr. S to leave his government position. Mr. S agreed to retire so that Mr. D could get appointed in his place. Government jobs cannot be transferred or obtained through private agreements. Government appointments must follow proper recruitment rules and procedures. Conclusion: The agreement is not valid and is void under Section 23 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872, because its object is opposed to public policy.

Related questions

What does Section 23 of the Indian Contract Act deal with?

It explains when consideration or object is lawful, and makes agreements with unlawful consideration or object void, including those opposed to public policy.

What is trafficking in public offices?

It means paying or receiving money to obtain, transfer or give up a public post. Such agreements are void because public posts must be filled on merit and proper procedure.

Can money paid under such a void agreement be enforced in court?

No. Neither party can enforce an agreement that is void for an unlawful object.

Have a doubt like this, or know the answer?

Ask and reply in the free Studycaller app. Students and Bruno answer fast.

Related doubts

  • CA FoundationCA Foundation Accounting - covering a syllabus backlog

    I have a lot left to cover in CA Foundation Accounts. Can anyone help and suggest how to finish it?

    Nitika

    First go for topics with heavy weightage use notes provided here from students and don't take theory lightly cause theory is literally free marks and try one shot videos after a meal to help u get motivated and also concept revision. Try using diff method and change places to study for better motivation and discipline and try to solve as many diff type of questions u can WITH TIME LIMIT cause that's the only problem at the time of exam hall we know how to solve it but we can't waste 30 min in a question and best of luckkk just don't take theory and easy topic lightly and do a lot hardwork for big weightage chapters and do test series and check suggested ans to know what all need to be present according to icai ans

    Read full answer →

    2 answers 17 Nov 2026

  • CA FoundationContinuous random variable - mean and variance from PDF

    How do you find the mean and standard deviation of X if its PDF is f(x) = 6x(1 − x) for 0 ≤ x ≤ 1?

    pusha

    The mean (or expected value) \(\mu = E(X)\) of a continuous random variable is found by integrating \(x \cdot f(x)\) over its defined interval: \(\mu =E(X)=\int _{0}^{1}x\cdot f(x)\,dx\) Substitute \(f(x) = 6x(1 - x)\) into the integral: \(E(X)=\int _{0}^{1}x\cdot 6x(1-x)\,dx=6\int _{0}^{1}(x^{2}-x^{3})\,dx\) Evaluate the definite integral: \(E(X)=6\left[\frac{x^{3}}{3}-\frac{x^{4}}{4}\right]_{0}^{1}\) \(E(X)=6\left(\frac{1}{3}-\frac{1}{4}\right)=\frac{\mathbf{1}}{\mathbf{2}}\text{\ (or\ }\mathbf{0.5}\text{)}\) Step 2: Find \(E(X^2)\) and Variance • Second Moment \(E(X^2)\): Integrating \(x^2 \cdot 6x(1-x)\) from \(0\) to \(1\) yields: \(E(X^{2})=6\left[\frac{x^{4}}{4}-\frac{x^{5}}{5}\right]_{0}^{1}=\frac{3}{10}\text{\ (or\ }0.3\text{)}\) • Variance & Standard Deviation: Using \(\text{Var}(X) = E(X^2) - [E(X)]^2\): \(\text{Var}(X)=\frac{3}{10}-\left(\frac{1}{2}\right)^{2}=\frac{1}{20}\text{\ (or\ }0.05\text{)}\) \(\sigma =\sqrt{\frac{1}{20}}=\frac{\mathbf{1}}{\mathbf{2}\sqrt{\mathbf{5}}}\approx \mathbf{0.2236}\)

    Read full answer →

    4 answers 17 Nov 2026

  • CA FoundationDepreciation - change from WDV to SLM method

    How do I solve question 34 on Machinery Account with a change from WDV to SLM depreciation?

    BrunoAI answer

    Q34: closing Machinery A/c balance on 31.12.2018 = Rs. 9,45,300, with total depreciation of Rs. 1,23,900 and a loss on sale of Rs. 15,800. Under AS 10, the change from WDV to SLM is a change in estimate, so it applies prospectively from 2018 at 10% of original cost. 1. Original cost: 9,72,000 / (0.9 x 0.9) = 12,00,000 2. Machine sold (cost 80,000): WDV on 1.1.18 = 64,800. Dep 6 months = 4,000. WDV = 60,800. Sold for 45,000, so loss = 15,800. 3. Remaining machines (cost 11,20,000): dep = 1,12,000 4. New machine (1,50,000 + 8,000 = 1,58,000): dep 6 months = 7,900 Machinery A/c 2018 Dr: Bal b/d 9,72,000; Bank 1,58,000 = 11,30,000 Cr: Bank 45,000; P&L (loss) 15,800; Depreciation 1,23,900; Bal c/d 9,45,300 = 11,30,000 Worth matching with your ICAI study material solution.

    Read full answer →

    1 answer 17 Nov 2026

  • CA FoundationBusiness Laws - study method and answer writing

    How should I study Business Laws for CA Foundation?

    Aayush· 1 found helpful

    Skip Ch 1 and 7 so you can skip Ques 4 completely only studied Remaining 5 chapters with youtube and than wrote notes strictly and revise them 3 to 4 times in week so you understand them then write questions from any question bank or from online.

    Read full answer →

    8 answers 16 Nov 2026

See all CA Foundation doubts

Free app · 5 lakh+ learners

Ask your doubt in the Studycaller app

Read full notes, ask doubts, follow toppers and track your study hours — free on Android and iPhone.