CA Foundation doubt
How do I solve question 34 on Machinery Account with a change from WDV to SLM depreciation?
Question number 34
Question number 34
Asked by Keshav··1 answer
CA Foundation doubt
Question number 34
Question number 34
Asked by Keshav··1 answer
BrunoAI answerAI first answer — verify with your teacher
Q34: closing Machinery A/c balance on 31.12.2018 = Rs. 9,45,300, with total depreciation of Rs. 1,23,900 and a loss on sale of Rs. 15,800. Under AS 10, the change from WDV to SLM is a change in estimate, so it applies prospectively from 2018 at 10% of original cost. 1. Original cost: 9,72,000 / (0.9 x 0.9) = 12,00,000 2. Machine sold (cost 80,000): WDV on 1.1.18 = 64,800. Dep 6 months = 4,000. WDV = 60,800. Sold for 45,000, so loss = 15,800. 3. Remaining machines (cost 11,20,000): dep = 1,12,000 4. New machine (1,50,000 + 8,000 = 1,58,000): dep 6 months = 7,900 Machinery A/c 2018 Dr: Bal b/d 9,72,000; Bank 1,58,000 = 11,30,000 Cr: Bank 45,000; P&L (loss) 15,800; Depreciation 1,23,900; Bal c/d 9,45,300 = 11,30,000 Worth matching with your ICAI study material solution.
No. Under AS 10, a change in depreciation method is treated as a change in accounting estimate and is applied prospectively.
Find the book value on the date of sale after charging depreciation up to that date, then subtract the sale proceeds. If proceeds are lower, the difference is a loss debited to P&L.
Yes, costs needed to bring the asset to working condition, such as installation, are added to its cost.
Ask and reply in the free Studycaller app. Students and Bruno answer fast.
CA FoundationBusiness Laws - study method and answer writing
Aayush· 1 found helpful
Skip Ch 1 and 7 so you can skip Ques 4 completely only studied Remaining 5 chapters with youtube and than wrote notes strictly and revise them 3 to 4 times in week so you understand them then write questions from any question bank or from online.
Read full answer →
7 answers 16 Nov 2026
CA FoundationCompound interest - finding rate from P: CI ratio
Krisha
(b) 0.1666
Read full answer →
3 answers 16 Nov 2026
CA FoundationCA Foundation - starting preparation and exam pattern
1 answer 16 Nov 2026
CA FoundationSimple interest - finding time from two amounts
Mital
Pan aema 0.08t kevi rite aavya
Read full answer →
5 answers 16 Nov 2026
CA FoundationBalancing exams with CA Foundation study
Gowtham· 1 found helpful
Don't prepare separately for b.com, just study the topics which are overlapping with our CA syllabus by using foundation books or your institute material ( if any)
Read full answer →
4 answers 16 Nov 2026
CA FoundationAdam Smith - Wealth of Nations
pusha
B is right answer
Read full answer →
6 answers 16 Nov 2026
Free app · 5 lakh+ learners
Read full notes, ask doubts, follow toppers and track your study hours — free on Android and iPhone.