CA Inter doubt
Is my answer to sub-question (iv) on average stock level correct?
Sub question iv is correct
Sub question iv is correct
Asked by Kiran··1 answer
CA Inter doubt
Sub question iv is correct
Sub question iv is correct
Asked by Kiran··1 answer
BrunoAI answerAI first answer — verify with your teacher
Most likely not. The teacher circled 32,250 in red instead of ticking it, and the formula is off. 1. Average stock level = Minimum stock level + 1/2 x ROQ or = 1/2 x (Maximum stock level + Minimum stock level). 2. Your working, 1/2 x (ROQ + Minimum stock), also halves the minimum stock. That is the error. 3. You seem to have used 52,500, which is C's re-order level from (iii). Use A's own minimum stock instead, i.e. 27,600 from (i). So the answer is 27,600 + 1/2 x ROQ of A. If ROQ of A is 12,000, that gives 33,600. If A's ROQ is different, share a photo of the question page and I'll confirm the exact figure.
Minimum stock level = Re-order level - (Normal consumption x Normal re-order period).
Maximum stock level = Re-order level + Re-order quantity - (Minimum consumption x Minimum re-order period).
Both are accepted in ICAI study material. If the question does not say which to use, state the formula you have applied.
Ask and reply in the free Studycaller app. Students and Bruno answer fast.
CA InterCompanies Act 2013 - important sections for revision
BrunoAI answer
Great plan to go section-wise! You can search "Corporate Law sections" in the app's Notes tab. The related notes listed below have full chapter-wise section and form lists (note 4 is a handy "Super 50" revision list). Quick starters: - Share Capital & Debentures: 43, 54, 55, 62, 63, 66, 67, 68, 71 - Management & Administration: 88, 92, 96, 100, 101, 103, 114, 118 - Accounts of Companies: 128, 129, 130, 131, 134, 135 (CSR), 136, 137 Amendments can change things, so check the latest ICAI study material and RTP for your attempt.
Read full answer →
1 answer 18 Nov 2026
CA InterIncome tax - surcharge rates under old regime
Pranitha
50L - 1cr =10% 1cr -2cr=15% 2cr-5cr=25% 5cr=37%
Read full answer →
3 answers 18 Nov 2026
CA InterCompanies Act 2013 - variation of shareholders' rights
Takumi
New preference shares pari-passu: Same rights wale new shares issue karna is not variation of class rights. 2. Cancellation / reduction of share capital: Shares cancel karna ya capital reduce karna is not variation of class rights.
Read full answer →
2 answers 18 Nov 2026
CA InterCompanies Act 2013 - variation of shareholders' rights
BrunoAI answer
Generally no. Issuing new equity shares that rank pari passu (equally) with existing equity shares is not a variation of the existing holders' class rights. The same logic as point (a) applies. - A class right is what each share carries: vote, dividend, capital return. The new shares carry identical rights, so the old shares' rights are unchanged. - What changes is only the enjoyment or value of those rights, such as diluted control or dividend per head. Courts treat this as an effect on enjoyment, not a variation. - Dilution is checked separately. Under Section 62, a further issue normally goes first to existing equity holders as a rights issue, unless the shareholders approve otherwise. - It could be a variation if the new shares carry superior rights, or if the company's terms of issue or Articles say such an issue needs class consent. Tip: check the ICAI study material for Section 48 in the latest attempt.
Read full answer →
1 answer 18 Nov 2026
CA InterAS 25 - Interim Financial Reporting
Sumit
Yes I have
Read full answer →
3 answers 18 Nov 2026
CA InterAS 24 - Discontinuing Operations
Ashok
Join bb virtuals channel
Read full answer →
4 answers 18 Nov 2026
Free app · 5 lakh+ learners
Read full notes, ask doubts, follow toppers and track your study hours — free on Android and iPhone.