Skip to content

CA Inter doubt

How do you solve the first case-scenario question of the CA Inter Taxation MTP paper, with explanations?

1st paper 1st question answers with explanation

1st paper 1st question answers with explanation

View attached PDF

Asked by Yashasvi··1 answer

1 reply

  1. BrunoAI answerAI first answer — verify with your teacher

    MTP 1, Q1 (Mr. Kamal) as per the ICAI key: (i) d, (ii) a, (iii) a. (i) 35AD deduction = Rs 150 lakhs (d) - A new three-star hotel is a specified business. He opted out of 115BAC, so 35AD is available. - Expenditure on land is excluded from 35AD, both the Rs 50 lakhs capitalised on 1.4.2025 and the Rs 50 lakhs bought in 2025-26. - Only the building qualifies: 100% of Rs 1.50 crore = Rs 150 lakhs. (ii) PGBP income = Rs 75 lakhs (a) - New hotel: 85 - 150 = loss of Rs 65 lakhs. - Under sec 73A, a specified business loss can be set off only against another specified business. ICAI treats the Ahmedabad four-star hotel as one. - So 140 - 65 = Rs 75 lakhs. (iii) 80JJAA: not eligible (a) - Sec 35AD(4): once 35AD is claimed for a specified business, no Chapter VI-A "C" deduction is allowed for that business. - 80JJAA falls under heading C, and the new employees are in the new hotel. So no deduction, even though the employee conditions look met. Tip: land is never part of 35AD. Check the ICAI answer section of this MTP (page 69) and the latest study material for your attempt.

Related questions

Is cost of land eligible for deduction under Section 35AD?

No. Expenditure on acquiring land is specifically excluded from the 35AD deduction, so only the building and other qualifying capital costs count.

Can a specified business loss be set off against normal business income?

No. Under Section 73A, such a loss can be set off only against income from another specified business and can be carried forward for that purpose.

Is Section 35AD available under the new tax regime of Section 115BAC?

No. A taxpayer under the default regime of Section 115BAC cannot claim 35AD, so the deduction is available only if the taxpayer has opted out of it.

Have a doubt like this, or know the answer?

Ask and reply in the free Studycaller app. Students and Bruno answer fast.

Related doubts

See all CA Inter doubts

Free app · 5 lakh+ learners

Ask your doubt in the Studycaller app

Read full notes, ask doubts, follow toppers and track your study hours — free on Android and iPhone.