Skip to content

CA Foundation doubt

Can you check my answer on whether a lender sharing profits is a partner, allot marks and point out my

Check my answer and allot me marks and find out my mistakes and give me appropriate answer

Check my answer and allot me marks and find out my mistakes and give me appropriate answer

Image attached to the doubt: Check my answer and allot me marks and find out my mistakes and give me…

Asked by Vedika··2 answers

2 replies

  1. BrunoAI answerAI first answer — verify with your teacher

    Your conclusion is correct: Shankar is only a lender, not a partner. Rough estimate: about 3 to 3.5 out of 4. This is indicative only; the actual marking depends on the ICAI scheme. What you did well: - You quoted Section 4 and its elements. - You used Section 6: the real relation is judged from all relevant facts. - You concluded clearly. Where you lost marks: 1. Cite Section 6, Explanation 2(a) directly: a lender who receives a share of profits does not become a partner. 2. The point on joint owners sharing gross returns (Explanation 1) isn't relevant here. Drop it. 3. Stress the missing mutual agency and business participation: Shankar has no role in running the business. 4. Add one line saying Shankar's claim to friends doesn't make him a partner.

  2. Daisydesk

    Upload clear photos

Related questions

Does sharing profits make a person a partner?

No. Sharing profits is not conclusive proof of partnership; the true relationship, especially mutual agency, must be examined from all facts.

What is mutual agency in a partnership?

It means each partner acts both as an agent of the firm and of the other partners, so the business is carried on by all or any of them acting for all.

How should a case study answer in Business Laws be structured?

State the relevant provision, apply it to the facts, and give a clear conclusion, avoiding provisions that do not relate to the facts.

Have a doubt like this, or know the answer?

Ask and reply in the free Studycaller app. Students and Bruno answer fast.

Related doubts

  • CA FoundationCA Foundation preparation - Maths and Accounts techniques

    What are better study techniques for Maths and Accounts to score 80+ in my second CA Foundation attempt?

    Web· 1 found helpful

    Accounts Do company accounts easy final accounts easy Npo Medium Parterner ship medium Boe easy inventory easy Depreciation easy Rectification easy Trick Incomplete record and Hard death of partner and next unit and Math do 9 to 12 , 4 18 2 3 13 16 coverup approx 60 marks and do 14 15 17 coverup approx 80 marks

    Read full answer →

    6 answers 18 Nov 2026

  • CA FoundationCA Foundation Accounting - study approach

    Accounts feels very difficult to study for CA Foundation. How can I manage it?

    pusha

    1. Master the basics first: golden rules / accounting equation, journal entries, ledger and trial balance. Every later chapter builds on these. 2. Solve, don't read: do 5-10 ICAl study material illustrations daily with your own pen, then match with the solution. 3. Keep a mistake notebook and redo wrong sums after 2-3 days. 4. Later, practise RTP/MTP questions with a timer.

    Read full answer →

    5 answers 18 Nov 2026

  • CA FoundationDoctrine of Indoor Management and consideration by a third party

    What is the suggested answer to this Business Laws case study question?

    BrunoAI answer

    The question line for ZKA is not visible, so I am answering the usual ask: can the Bank hold the company liable even though no board resolution was passed? Yes, under the Doctrine of Indoor Management (Royal British Bank v. Turquand). 1. Constructive notice: outsiders are deemed to know the MOA and AOA, and the Bank did check both. 2. Outsiders acting in good faith need not inquire into internal proceedings, such as whether a resolution was actually passed. 3. Exceptions (knowledge of the irregularity, suspicion, negligence, forgery) do not apply here. Conclusion: the loan is binding and the company is liable to repay. For part (ii): yes, the father's consideration is valid, since consideration may move from the promisee or any other person (Sec 2(d), Chinnaya v. Ramayya).

    Read full answer →

    1 answer 18 Nov 2026

See all CA Foundation doubts

Free app · 5 lakh+ learners

Ask your doubt in the Studycaller app

Read full notes, ask doubts, follow toppers and track your study hours — free on Android and iPhone.