Skip to content

CA Foundation doubt

Can you check my answer on a deceased partner's liability, give marks and show the correct answer format?

Now check my this answer and allot marks and tell in exact full format how should I write the answer

Now check my this answer and allot marks and tell in exact full format how should I write the answer

Image attached to the doubt: Now check my this answer and allot marks and tell in exact full format how…

Asked by Vedika··2 answers

2 replies

  1. BrunoAI answerAI first answer — verify with your teacher

    Your conclusion is correct: Mr. X cannot recover from Mr. C's legal heirs. I'd estimate about 2 out of 3, because you missed the key point about his name still being on the board and letter-head. Scoring format (ICAI style): 1. Provisions: - Section 35: if the firm continues after a partner's death, his estate is not liable for acts of the firm done after his death. No public notice is needed. - Section 28(2) (the point you missed): continued use of the old firm name, or the deceased partner's name, does not by itself make his legal heirs or estate liable for acts after his death. 2. Analysis: Mr. C died on 1 Oct 2018. Mr. X supplied the furniture on 16 Oct 2018, after the death. His name on the board and letter-head creates no liability under Section 28(2). 3. Conclusion: Mr. X can recover only from M/s ABC & Co. and partners A and B. Mr. C's legal heirs are not liable. Tip: drop the general dissolution lines. They earn no marks here.

  2. Gauriii

    It's 1.5 according to me...as aapke provisions shii h but aapne relate karne m thodi Kami rakhi h it can improve a bit and conclusion shii nhi h like usse ek baar clearly likhna hoga alg se chahe 2 line m...

Related questions

Is public notice needed when a partner dies?

No. Public notice is required on retirement or expulsion, but not on the death of a partner, so his estate is not liable for later acts of the firm.

How should CA Foundation law practical questions be answered?

State the relevant provisions first, apply them to the facts in the question, and end with a clear conclusion. Avoid unrelated general theory.

Who is liable for debts incurred after a partner's death?

The firm and the continuing partners are liable; the deceased partner's legal heirs are not.

Have a doubt like this, or know the answer?

Ask and reply in the free Studycaller app. Students and Bruno answer fast.

Related doubts

See all CA Foundation doubts

Free app · 5 lakh+ learners

Ask your doubt in the Studycaller app

Read full notes, ask doubts, follow toppers and track your study hours — free on Android and iPhone.